Home - Desserts - Holiday Cookies to Make and Share

Holiday Cookies to Make and Share

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.

How to package and decorate a pretty holiday cookie box for giving, and the best cookies to make and share.

Easy Holiday Cookie Recipes to Make and Share

Whether or not your family baking traditions involve epic baking sessions, elaborate decorative icings or something more straightforward, making homemade cookies and packaging them as gifts is literally one of the sweetest ways to share the holiday love.

My favorite Christmas cookies to make are the ones that are homey, simple and not too fussy.

Read on to get the most popular holiday cookie recipes from Familystyle Food, plus ideas for packaging up the goodies for giving!

Easy Holiday Cookie Recipes to Make and Share

The best cookies for gift-giving:

  • Choose cookies that aren’t too delicate.
  • Variety in shape, size and texture is ideal.
  • Include a few different cookies to mix things up.

Try making two, three or more different kinds:

  • Crunchy and sturdy: Biscotti, shortbread or gingerbread.
  • Dense and chewy — Chocolate chip, peanut butter, oatmeal, sugar cookies.
  • Bar cookies — Brownies, blondies, fudge, nut bars.

How to pack cookies for holiday gifts

Pile a bunch of cookies in a box and hand them off with a bow on top — it’s not exactly rocket science.

However, the secret to transforming an otherwise humble package of baked goods into something memorable all comes down to presentation.

Even adding a handwritten tag to a plain brown paper bag of homemade cookies adds a touch that comes straight from the heart.

The Best Easy Christmas Cookie Recipes

Containers for packaging holiday cookies

  • Choose a sturdy container like a covered tin or plain heavy cardboard. I love this wooden box, with a sliding top and compartments for each cookie stack. It can be used over and over, and it’s sturdy enough for transporting your creations without crushing or crumbling them.
  • Line the container with parchment or wax paper. If you can find festive food-friendly tissue paper, use it for wrapping stacks of cookies.
  • For shipping the cookies, cut out a sheet of bubble wrap to fit into the bottom of the container, adding more between layers.
  • Use large muffin or cupcake liners or other dividers like pieces of cardboard to organize the cookies.
  • Fill spaces in between the cookies with crinkled gift basket paper, crumpled foil or tissue.

Decorating cookie boxes or bags

Make your gift package some holiday flair by embellishing it with a few inexpensive items, easily found in stationary or craft stores.

  • Fabric ribbons and rustic jute twine
  • Plain gift tags or labels to write on
  • Tissue paper (if you’re wrapping cookies directly in tissue, use food-safe paper)
  • Kraft paper and bags

If your container has a lid, tie a ribbon around it and add a gift tag attached with a piece of twine or colorful string.

For containers without a lid, securely wrap in plastic or cellophane before adding a ribbon.

Easy cookie recipes for making and sharing

If you’re looking for recipes that are easy to make and perfect for gifting, here’s a sample of the cookies I used in my holiday cookie box:

Rosemary Lemon Cornmeal Cookies

Rosemary Lemon Cornmeal Cookies

Rustic Almond Jam Cookies

Rustic Almond Apricot Jam Cookies

Double Dark Chocolate Biscotti

Double Dark Chocolate Biscotti

Hazelnut and Cocoa Snowballs

Chocolate Hazelnut Butterball Cookies

Save this post on Pinterest:

How to Make a Pretty Homemade Christmas Cookie Gift Box

Hey, I’m Karen

Creator of Familystyle Food

I’m a food obsessed super-taster and professionally trained cook ALL about making cooking fun and doable, with easy to follow tested recipes and incredibly tasty food! Read more about me here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. It’s hard to share them how delicious they look 😉 Love it!

  2. Your post is really inspiring me to bake! I even wish I had a cookie swap to go to! XO