raw and roasted cherry tomato salad

August is the month that feels most like summer to me, when days melt lazily into each other and the sun feels that much warmer. It’s the perfect time to unplug. When we lived in the Midwest, my kids would start the new school year in early August, which never failed to feel strangely out of step – it was always September when I was growing up. This year it felt nice to push our vacation into that last full month of summer.

We spent a few weeks on the coast of Rhode Island; almost every day was so clear and beautiful, each sunset outdoing the last. I didn’t want it to end.  Nothing makes me happier than looking at the ocean all day, and planning dinner around produce from the local farmstand – at this point in the summer that would be tomatoes, sweet corn, blueberries…and more tomatoes.

The cherry tomatoes I found at the market the other day were hard to resist, in a rainbow of colors. Usually my daughter eats them up by the handful straight out of the pint basket, as if they were the cherries they’re named after. Before they disappeared, I got the idea to make a cooked and raw salad,  to get a little bit of the intensity I love about roasted tomatoes along with the burst of juicy freshness from uncooked ones. 

Now we’re back home, enjoying  a few more days until the fall routine begins.

And I’m absolutely thrilled to share some great news  —  the folks at Da Vinci Wine have announced the 2014 Storytellers – and I am one!

I will be traveling to Tuscany in a few weeks (I can’t believe I just said that…!) and will have lots to share before, during and after this great adventure. Stay tuned.

raw and roasted cherry tomato salad

Serving Size: 4

raw and roasted cherry tomato salad

Soft, sweet roasted tomatoes and juicy fresh raw tomatoes make a pleasant contrast of flavors and textures in this salad. This would be great as a topping for pasta too. White balsamic has a light, subtle flavor I prefer over regular balsamic, which could overwhelm this simplicity of the tomatoes. Lemon juice makes a good substitute.


  • 3 pints cherry tomatoes, in assorted colors; halved
  • 1 garlic clove, smashed, peeled and roughly chopped
  • 1/4 cup extra virgin olive oil
  • Kosher salt
  • 1/4 teaspoon sugar
  • 2 teaspoons white balsamic vinegar or fresh lemon juice
  • A few handfuls fresh arugula and torn basil leaves
  • Sliced burrata or buffalo mozzarella


  1. Heat oven to 425 degrees.
  2. Toss 2 pints of the tomatoes in a shallow baking dish with the garlic and olive oil; season with salt to taste.
  3. Roast tomatoes until they become shriveled and softened, 20 - 25 minutes. Cool to room temperature.
  4. Transfer the tomatoes along with all the juices in the baking dish to a serving bowl.
  5. Stir in the remaining raw tomatoes; sprinkle with the sugar and vinegar and gently combine.
  6. Serve tomatoes on a plate over the arugula, basil and sliced mozzarella (burrata or buffalo mozzarella is especially creamy and delicious).


  1. shirley D says:

    Congratulations, Karen … I’m SO happy you won this trip. Tuscany was one of my favorite places (even tho I was last there when single …. and I’ve been married over 50 years now!); my daughter has been to Tuscany 2 or 3 times over the last 10 years and it still sounds wonderful! Enjoy!

    The recipe sounds delicious … our tomtoes have been very prolific this year.

    • Shirley, thank you. Really, over 50 years?! You are an amazing woman. And I have a feeling Tuscany is timelessly beautiful, just as your daughter found it. I’m feeling so grateful for this trip. Glad it’s a good year for the tomatoes 🙂

  2. Such a gorgeous salad! I’m so thrilled for you – half of my heart is in Italy :). Hope you’ll be posting photos on Instagram so we can live vicariously through you!

    • Laura, I would pack you in my suitcase if I could. I’ll be sure to document as much as I can on Instagram and elsewhere so please keep in touch!

  3. I am loving the vibrant colours and fresh flavours of this salad. I definitely need to try the recipe out… looks delicious. Pinned!

  4. Yaaay! Congratulations! Whoo hooo!

  5. I just show this recipe to my mom, she will try this tonight…. as we r having a party in our home…. nice idea Karen

  6. Your article is very useful and have good knowledgeable content, thanks for the post.


  1. […] for juicy brined pork chops is a variation on one I’ve been making for years. While I was in Tuscany during my DaVinci Storyteller experience earlier this fall, I soaked up the aura and sensory beauty […]

Leave a Comment